Shooting, Printing, Cropping

topic posted Tue, December 5, 2006 - 7:11 PM by  Xeena
This topic kind of came up before but I wanted to open a new thread. I've looked at the following:

35mm film 24mm x 36mm Ratio: 1:1.5
D200 digital camera 8.64" x 12.907" Ratio 1:1.5

4x6 Ratio 1:1.5

But...
5x7 Ratio: 1:1.4
8x10 Ratio: 1:25
8x11 Ratio: 1:1.38
11x14 Ratio: 1:1.27

I'm really starting to question how I want to shoot. Because most clients don't want a 4x6 print. And sometimes they may want a 5x7 but they might also want an 8x10. Ideally I'd like to frame exactly how I'd like something printed without cropping.

How do you handle this dilemma?
posted by:
Xeena
  • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

    Tue, December 5, 2006 - 7:54 PM
    Just shoot how it feels good.I never shoot thinking of how
    someone else will like my images.They are rarely cropped,but if they are I think another crop-compposition is possible
    Great pictures can always be altered a little in size and composition.Sometimes I love a square..a panorama
    Mediocre and just good pics..are harder to crop..thats my 2cents..
  • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

    Tue, December 5, 2006 - 9:03 PM
    >How do you handle this dilemma?

    You don't. When you print an 8X10 from a DSLR or 35mm, you're going to lose 1/6 of the frame. Compose accordingly. As an option, there are other sizes available from labs that use the Fujifilm "Frontier" printing system.

    8x12... 1.5:1
    10x15...1.5:1
    Or for larger format printers, like the Ultrachrome Epsons,
    12x18...1.5:1
    16x24...1.5:1

    Most labs charge the same amount for an 8x12 as an 8x10, and it's not much harder to find frames.
    • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

      Tue, December 5, 2006 - 9:38 PM
      Then of course there is the Olympus E system, and the Panasonic DSLR and one of the Leicas which all shoot in the "Four thirds" format which brings you closer to that 4x5 or 8x10.
    • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

      Wed, December 6, 2006 - 12:26 AM
      just tell the lab to print full frame with the borders on... problems solved... you get your entire image on to paper... just cut off the excess
      • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

        Thu, December 7, 2006 - 7:58 AM
        A camera that shoots in 4:3 aspect ratio does reduce the amount of cropping for standard frame sizes.

        The problem with printing a no-crop image is that you can't find a frame for it. You're stuck either buying a custom frame (spendy) or buying a standard frame and matting it down for your image size (cheaper, but still inconvenient and often not quite as tidy, especially with really odd sizes.
    • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

      Thu, December 7, 2006 - 5:53 PM
      Is that true that it's not much harder to find an 8x12 frame than an 8x10 frame?

      I don't always have the luxury to compose for each print the client may or may not want. If I was talking about personal and/or fine art work, it wouldn't be such an issue. The shooting might be more leisurely and I might be shooting with the final print in mind.
  • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

    Sun, May 4, 2008 - 1:31 AM
    Yes, it's quite a dilemma. And don't even start with European standard frame sizes . . . :-)

    Personally, I'm a full frame gal. I compose when I shoot. You don't mention what kind of clients you work with, but when I do portrait work, I'll print cropped or full frame depending on the client's request. It's their portrait afterall.

    As for art prints, it's always full frame, and I'll do a custom mat. Really, if the print is truly a work of art, then custom matting or framing is a small investment. And besides, would a client tell a painter, "That's great, but can you do that in a 11x14 to fit my frame instead?" (Okay, some do say that, but it's rude.)

    Then for commercial clients, ratio is basically irrelevant, since marketing will crop at will.

    Just some general thoughts, but it's your work and your vision, so it's all about what you want your prints to be.
  • Re: Shooting, Printing, Cropping

    Sun, May 4, 2008 - 7:42 AM
    If you have access to tethered laptop or computer using Capture one software will solve your problem, by shooting directly to the puter, there are preset frame sizes which you are able to frame out with your subjects.

Recent topics in "PHOTOGRAPHY"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Travel Pictures Country next to Country BoBi 1 Today, 6:03 AM
SF pride 2 June 27, 2008
Advice for violent crowds 15 June 25, 2008
photographers being harrassed by police skooter 2 June 25, 2008